Increase online store sales: nine lessons the big stores measured
Nine lessons large online stores measured, each with its source and its number, translated for a business that sells through Instagram DMs.
Published: November 3, 20264 min read

To increase online store sales, most shops reach for more followers. The cheaper lever is getting more of the people who already message you to finish a purchase, and to come back. Here are nine of their lessons, each with its source and its number, translated for a shop that sells through Instagram DMs.
One caveat first: most of this research was run on US and European websites, not in DMs. Use the numbers for direction, not as a forecast.
To increase online store sales, move three numbers
Weekly sales are the people who ask, times the share who buy, times how often and how much each customer comes back. A worked example: 200 buying conversations a week at a 10 percent conversion rate is 20 orders. Lift conversion to 12 percent and you have 24 orders with no new follower and no extra ad spend.
| Lesson | Source | Key number |
|---|---|---|
| Photos first | Baymard | 56% start with the images |
| Surprise costs | Baymard | 40% quit over extra costs |
| Payment trust | Baymard | 19% did not trust the site with a card |
| Forced sign-up | Baymard | 18% quit over account creation |
| Reviews | Spiegel Research Center | Five reviews: 270% higher purchase likelihood |
| Past customers | Harvard Business Review | A new customer costs 5 to 25 times more |
Shoppers look at photos before they read
In Baymard's product page testing, 56 percent of participants started by exploring the images and 42 percent tried to judge size from them, yet 28 percent of 60 large stores had no in-scale shot. Google's rules for a main product image ban prices, promo text, borders and watermarks. The full shot list is in product photography with a phone.
Write the description that answers the DM
Baymard saw every single participant rely on the description at some point, but only 22 percent of sites structure it around two to six core features. Nielsen Norman Group adds two rules: front-load the key facts, and keep details consistent across every size and colour. A line-by-line template is in writing a product description.
Show the full cost in the first answer
Baymard averages 50 studies to a 70.22 percent cart abandonment rate. Excluding people just browsing, 40 percent quit over extra costs and 12 percent because they could not see the total up front. Quote delivery next to the price. See shipping costs for an online shop and the full abandoned cart breakdown.
Make paying feel safe
Among Baymard's abandoners, 19 percent did not trust the site with their card. The Spiegel Research Center found that a product with five reviews is 270 percent more likely to be bought than one with none, and that purchase likelihood peaks at 4.0 to 4.7 stars, not a perfect 5. More in customer trust on Instagram and payment links for Instagram sales.
Cut every extra step
Baymard reports that 18 percent left over forced account creation and 17 percent over a long checkout, and estimates a large site can gain 35.26 percent in conversion from checkout design alone. In a DM, a long checkout is an address collected over five messages. Compare the options in taking orders from Instagram DMs.
Answer before they ask the next shop
Meta lets a business message someone only within 24 hours of that person's last message, so a slow reply can close the conversation for good. What to automate and when to step in is in Instagram DM auto-replies.
Sell to people who already bought
Harvard Business Review notes that acquiring a customer costs five to 25 times more than keeping one, and cites Bain research in which a 5 percent lift in retention raised profits by 25 to 95 percent. The range spans many industries, so read it as direction. Grouping buyers is covered in customer loyalty for an online shop.
Plan the peak season early
Big retailers plan their peak weeks well ahead: stock the best sellers, publish a last order day, message past buyers first. A four week version is in the holiday sales plan.
Measure one change at a time
Hold one change for two weeks and compare it with the same weekdays before. The numbers worth watching are in online shop sales reports.
Tomorrow morning
- 1Add the delivery cost to your saved price reply.
- 2Replace the card number in DMs with a payment link.
- 3Shoot one in-scale photo for each of your five best sellers.
- 4Complete those five descriptions: material, size, care.
- 5Message everyone who bought in the last three months.
- 6Compare two weeks of sales before and after.
If orders and stock are not in one place yet, start with online shop management.
Frequently asked questions
Can you increase online store sales without ads?
Up to a point, yes. Ads raise the number of conversations, while most of the lessons here work on the other two numbers: the share who buy and how often they return. While half the conversations leak away, more ads only pay for a bigger leak.
What is a good conversion rate for an Instagram shop?
No reliable public benchmark exists for DM sales, and website figures do not compare. Divide this week's orders by this week's buying conversations, then judge every change against that number.
Does free shipping increase sales?
It can, but free shipping is a discount with a new name, paid from your margin. Baymard's finding is about surprise costs. Stating the delivery fee in the first answer recovers many of those sales without giving the fee away.
How long before the results show?
For simple fixes like quoting delivery up front or sending a payment link, two weeks of sales is usually enough to compare. Repeat purchases take longer, because the gap between two orders from one customer can be several weeks.
Hand your online shop to ProMall
Explore the free demo and review orders, payments and inventory management.
Get a free demoRelated reading
Sales
Abandoned carts: what the research says and what an Instagram shop can fix
About 70 percent of carts are abandoned, and 42 percent of the shoppers who left a cart were only browsing. Why the rest left, and what an Instagram shop can fix this week.
Customers
Customer trust on Instagram: what a careful buyer checks before paying
Fake pages, an account number sent in a DM and nothing delivered: each fear paired with the signal that answers it and the place it lives on an Instagram page.
Content
Product descriptions that answer the questions your DMs keep asking
Where a product description lives for an Instagram shop, which line answers which repeated DM question, and what Baymard and Nielsen Norman Group found.